Mike Ashley wins High Court battle as judge puts £15m claim down to 'wishful thinking'
Investment banker Jeffrey Blue told a judge that Mr Ashley promised to pay him £15 million if he used his expertise to double Sports Direct's share price to £8 a share.
He said Mr Ashley paid only £1 million and he wanted £14 million damages.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdMr Ashley denied the claim and said Mr Blue was talking ''nonsense''.
Mr Justice Leggatt heard that the dispute centred on a conversation in the Horse and Groom pub in Great Portland Street, central London four years ago.
The judge, who analysed evidence at a High Court trial in London earlier this month, on Wednesday dismissed Mr Blue's claim.
He said no-one at the pub would have thought any offer Mr Ashley made was serious.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdThe judge said Mr Blue may have borne a grudge against Mr Ashley.
"In the course of a jocular conversation with three investment bankers in a pub on the evening of January 24 2013, Mr Ashley said that he would pay Mr Blue £15 million if Mr Blue could get the price of Sports Direct shares (then trading at around £4 per share) to £8," said Mr Justice Leggatt in a ruling.
"Mr Blue expressed his agreement to that proposal and everyone laughed.
"Thirteen months later the Sports Direct share price did reach £8.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide Ad"But no reasonable person present in the Horse and Groom on January 24 2013 would have thought that the offer to pay Mr Blue £15 million was serious and was intended to create a contract, and no one who was actually present in the Horse and Groom that evening - including Mr Blue - did in fact think so at the time.
"They all thought it was a joke.
"The fact that Mr Blue has since convinced himself that the offer was a serious one, and that a legally binding agreement was made, shows only that the human capacity for wishful thinking knows few bounds."
The judge told lawyers: "He (Mr Blue) may to some extent borne some degree of grudge against Mr Ashley."
Mr Ashley was not in court to hear the judge deliver his ruling.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdA barrister leading his legal team said he has won a "comprehensive victory".
The businessman said afterwards in a statement: "The only reason the Sports Direct share price exceeded £8.00, and will hopefully do so again, is because of the sterling efforts of all the people who work at Sports Direct."