Is retrofitting the solution for old homes facing rising energy costs? - Paul Testa
Yes, it certainly is; but only when approached holistically. Unless you think about your home as a
complete system, changing one element with a view to retrofitting it, may affect other areas and cause
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide Adunexpected problems. Before embarking on an energy efficiency project for your old property, you need
to come up with a complete retrofit renovation plan to avoid unwanted and unintended consequences.
Doing one thing on its own can often have unintended consequences which can give you additional
risks. These include interstitial condensation (condensation inside the construction) because of poorly
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide Addesigned additional insulation, and could damage the building and encourage mould growth out of
sight; thermal bridges, which can lead to cold spots and provide surfaces for potential condensation and
unhealthy mould growth; and reduced air quality due to the lack of a carefully designed ventilation
system.
The risks also vary based on the type of building you have. They’re far greater when it comes to a solid
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide Adwall construction than a cavity wall home, as the existing walls are dealing with external moisture as
well as moisture from internal humidity from occupation.
Phase your plan
By following a phased plan, you can mitigate your risks and minimise any negative impacts on your
home. Working towards an end goal and deciding what you can afford to do within a framework is very
important. You should decide what your retrofit renovation aims are; comfort, energy saving or carbon
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide Adreduction? Different measures will have different impacts. Airtightness works, ventilation and triple
glazed windows give the best improved comfort; whereas replacing your gas boiler with a heat pump
will see a big carbon reduction – but may not deliver a return on investment as quickly.
Good is better than perfect
We always recommend starting with the fabric of the home first; and do this to the best standard you
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide Adcan afford. Let’s say you insulate the roof of your home, but not to a very high standard. You’re unlikely
to ever go through the upheaval to revisit the insulation so that performance is locked in. You can
always add solar panels to the same roof at a later date. Good, rather than perfect, is probably the way
to go for most people. Find the right balance between cost and benefit and don’t let not beong perfect
put you off doing the work.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdUse natural insulation, like wood fibre, when you can. They’re breathable and cope with internal
moisture well. If you add plastic insulations, especially internally, they can trap moisture in the
construction, whereas natural fibres will absorb atmospheric moisture when it’s high relative humidity
but then will dry out again when it’s low relative humidity, keeping this risk low.
Better air quality
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdAir quality is hugely important for your and your home’s health. In most houses we only open the
windows and doors in the summer months, with all the other air coming through the cracks in the
construction, lowering the quality of the air you breathe. Making the building more airtight and adding a
mechanical ventilation system with heat recovery, while not cheap, is a good way of gaining excellent air
quality and not losing any heat in the winter.
The cost of sustainability
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdA typical retrofit will cost between £800-1,000 per m 2 , while an EnerPHit project (the Passivhaus retrofit
standard) reaches £1,300-£1,400 per m 2 . Compare that to a baseline of £1,650 m 2 for a new build and it’s
not the most attractive option cost-wise. While it does depend on where you live, it’s unlikely your
house will be worth what you’ve spent on it. The payback in bills is not short term either. You also need
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide Adto bear in mind the disruption. If you’re doing some light touch work, you can stay in the house, while if
you’re ripping everything out, you should take into account the temporary moving costs.
Reducing embodied carbon
Retrofitting your property is better than demolishing and rebuilding, as far as embodied carbon is
concerned. This term refers to the energy emitted during the construction of a house, generated
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide Adthrough production, transport, use and disposal of the materials used. The benefit of working with an
existing building, rather than a new build, is that a lot of the embodied carbon that was used in building
that structure in the first place isn’t thrown away; it’s kept and you’re only adding a small amount
compared to a new build.
There are many reasons why people decide to retrofit houses which fall short in terms of space, lifestyle
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide Adand performance, and saving energy and money can be among them. When done correctly, retrofitting
can provide you with low energy living, comfort and health, without the pain of moving.
For more information and guidance on retrofitting homes, why not visit the London Homebuilding and
Renovating Show, 30 September – 2 October 2022 at ExCeL, London.
- Paul Testa is director HEM architects and a retrofitting expert for the London Homebuilding and Renovating Show.